My updated lineup vrs Richmond

[BUCKS]

Collingwood vrs Richmond


B: Lockyer, Prestigiacomo, Walkelin

HB: Burns, Richardson, Clement

C: Licuria, O'Bree, Steinfort

HF: Rintoul, Rocca, N.Davis

F: L.Davis, Cummings, Tarrant

FL: McKee, Buckley, Holland

IN: Freeborn, Fraser, Scotland, Cloke

EMERG: Adkins, Richards, Kinnear, Didak

 

[bwphantom]

Yea good line up..only thing to change could be for Kinnear to get run instead of Cloke...But watch Cloke he will get run middle to late in season i reckon

If your not bleeding Black and White, you don't truly support Collingwood!!!!!

[MarkT]

Adkins is good enough to play in a top 4 team. Steinfort is not. I would swap them.

I do not believe we can win more than half our games with McKee in the ruck. He has played enough games to have won at least once in the ruck during his career. We do not need a fiollower, we need a ruckman. I would never play him again because I just don't see any point. Richards should be thrown in at the deep end. He probably isn't quite ready but frankly neither is McKee. At least Richards may be with experiance. If the match committe think it is too much risk to his development then Hill should be promoted and played until he either makes it of Richards is ready.

I have questions over Freeborn, Wakelin and Kinnear but they are as good as any other options at present. I expect them to be forced out by the years end by some emerging talent. The jury is still out on Rintoul IMO but I like his grunt at least so he should be given a go early.

Still a pretty good though at this stage and so much improvement expected.