COLL v ESS Free Kick Analysis

MargOZ · Joined: 08 May 2001 Location: Vic, Australia

Well, I was SO cheesed off with the umpiring last night that I sat down with the tape of the game today to actually check what the result would have been WITHOUT the umpires errors. After doing a full analysis of every free kick, this is what I came up with:

Collingwood 15 - 7 - 97
Essendon 10 - 20 - 80

I'm sure that we'll all admit the umpires aren't perfect BUT we were robbed of not only a great win against the bombers but a position back in the eight and it REALLY STINKS!

It's about time the umpires became accountable!

GO PIES!

Marg (who cursed the umpires for all of the 2 1/2 hour bus trip home after the game!!!).

email: margoz@tpg.com.au

[This message has been edited by MargOZ (edited 20 August 2001).]

stik35 · Joined: 22 May 2001 Location: VIC

I don't usually comment on umpiring decisions as there is no point, it doesn't change anything.
But having said that, I couldn't ignore some of their inexplicable decisions on Saturday night. It was even mentioned on the footy show on Sunday that with so many games and so few umpires that they must have been scraping the bottom of the barrel for our game.
They disallowed goals we should have been paid and gave Essendon some easy goals.
It changed the momentum of the game on several occassions to our detriment.
It's a pity Molloy didn't accidently knock out Jimmy instead of Tarks. Who would have received all the free kicks then?

MargOZ · Joined: 08 May 2001 Location: Vic, Australia

I usually don't complain too much about umpiring because I think some days it goes our way and other days it doesn't and usually (hopefully!) it evens out over a season BUT Saturday's night game was definitely the exception!

This is what I took into account when altering the scores which showed we would have won:

1. Minus 1 goal Ess (for stupid 50m penalty against Josh)
2. Minus 1 goal Ess (when out on full or Bucks free not given)
3. Change Ess goal to point (when Alessio not put on boundary line)
4. Change Ess goal to point (Freeborn was NOT holding ball!)
5. Change Ess goal to point (for unfair free against O'Bree - they were both holding each other!)
6. Plus 1 goal Coll (for Nick Davis goal given as a point)
7. Take 50m penalty from Rocca although he still would have kicked goal so no change to score
8. Plus 1 goal Coll (for Buckley goal that umpire disallowed)

I know it's in the past and we can't change the result and it's important for the team to look ahead to next week BUT the umpiring still stinks!

GO PIES!

Marg

Joel · Joined: 23 Mar 1999 Location: Mornington Peninsula

I'm sure you guys in the cheersquad saw that "goal" be Essendon when the ball hit the post. That is the worst goal umpiring decision I have seen for a long long time. PATHETIC, DISGRACEFUL, SHAMEFUL!!!!

JDF

stik35 · Joined: 22 May 2001 Location: VIC

Yeah Joel, we saw it but they didn't listen to us!

Pies rock · Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2001 11:34 am

I was at the other end so I didn't see that. Nothing would surprise me! I was sitting behond the Nick Davis goal they gave a point, couldn't believe it! They were bloody disgraceful all night. I was and still am absolutely furious. Go Pies, Carlton will cop our wrath.