What chance Guy Richards or Cameron Cloke ????

[drew1602]

Will Guy Richards or Cameron Cloke be considered soon in the ruck

I would much rather Josh stay on the ground up forward and have either of these boys come off the bench to swap with Mckee in the ruck

Any thoughts

[Cam]

No chance.

Why play them when so young? If they get a game and don't get a kick people will rag them and criticise their skills. Let them develop like good wine.

[natkingcole]

Why play them so young? One word. McKee

[Nic]

cloke's the more likely of the two at the moment to play this year, i'd think.

[hotpie]

Guy Richards? When was the last time he actually played for williamstown? Or does he play in the williamstown reserve team? Cloke would probably be considered first as hes named im willies best almost every week, but hes at least another year off, probably two and needs to bulk up. Im looking forward to Travis Cloke coming thru as hes the tallest of the 3 boys and is rumoured to be the best 1 of them.

[Dale61]

Hotpie, if you bothered to take the time to read the Williamstown reports in the VFL forum you will know when Richards last played for Williamstown, and to say that Cam Cloke needs to bulk up, are you serious? He already has the body (95kgs) to perform at the top level, but whether the selection panel are prepared to give him a go so soon in his career is only something that they can answer.

[freddie foxx]

yeah i wouldn't count on Richards getting a game, he's barely in the best players for willi reserves at the moment. He needs much time to develop, bulk and confidence wise. Cloke may get a seniors call up this year, but he is still quite underdone, seems to carry a lot of puppy fat which will be worked on next summer. Hopefully his foot skills are superior to his brothers (mind you j cloke makes up for his errors in kicking in his confidence fearlessness)