Maynard incident > Maynard rule > Brayshaw retirement

David · I dare you to try Joined: 27 Jul 2003 Location: Andromeda

I expect we’ll be hearing a lot about the Maynard incident with Brayshaw over the coming days, and it seems genuinely unclear to me how it’ll shake out.

Obviously all or most of us think that he should have no case to answer, and hopefully that’ll be how the MRP see it. But if not, needless to say we’ll be spending much of the next fortnight exhausting the appeals process until we get the right result.

Which way do you see this going?

Jezza · 2023 PREMIERS! Joined: 06 Sep 2010 Location: Ponsford End

Think he gets a week. It's a "football act" of trying to smother the ball, but the last part where he turns his body and shoulder will be heavily scrutinised.

Whatever the decision is, it will be polarising no matter what.

David · I dare you to try Joined: 27 Jul 2003 Location: Andromeda

I actually feel like that’s the least likely outcome in some ways – it seems to me either accidental and thus no case to answer, or else two given the impact if it’s assessed as negligent. The MRP might like to split the difference on that, but I’m not sure how that would actually work under their grading system.

Gerry Cooper · Joined: 23 Feb 2012

There are two potential incidents involving Cox they may look at too. An accidental elbow to some generic Melbourne gronk's head and that slide tackle he did.

Take_a_Screamer · Posted: Fri Sep 08, 2023 2:43 am

I think Maynard will get a week and we should be talking about his replacement

Brown26 · Posted: Fri Sep 08, 2023 6:48 am

I think it’s nothing or 3 weeks /
Either he’s responsible and knocked him out and it’s 3 weeks or it’s an accident and he gets nothing. You missed the option for 4 weeks, appeal, 8 weeks, appeal, delayed court challenge, Maynard plays in a fortnight, off on a technicality and Maynard wins the Brownlow … :p

-
Ben

Leggie · Bucks for PM. Joined: 12 Apr 2005 Location: Perth

If Cripps can get off then Maynard will get off plus an apology from Brayshaw for getting in his way

What'sinaname · Joined: 29 May 2010 Location: Living rent free

I suspect the MRO will send this through to the tribunal based on the outcome.

It's funny that if Maynard has dislocated Brayshaw's shoulder, or brokwn hisn arm, they'd all be saying that this was just bad luck - like the Howe's incident.

But given it was a concussion and the AFL's overreaction to that, who knows

Skids · Posted: Fri Sep 08, 2023 8:16 am

Van Rooyens hit on McStay was worse and he didn't even get a free kick!

Maynard will get 3 weeks, I ope he gets off but I just can't see it happening.

ANNODAM · Posted: Fri Sep 08, 2023 8:44 am

Any other player on any other team = nothing
A COLL player = 6wks

We always seem to have bad luck when it comes to player suspensions & finals.

What'sinaname · Joined: 29 May 2010 Location: Living rent free

aus50ford · Joined: 02 Oct 2018

There was no 'turning of the shoulder'
he brought his hands/arms forward to lessen the impact on himself and brayshaw

Mr Miyagi · Joined: 14 Sep 2018

shawthing · Joined: 04 Jul 2019 Location: Victoria Park

None of the above. Christian will send him straight to the tribunal. They'll give him 3 weeks. We will appeal and eventually win the right for him to play.

Mark my words the AFL tried to stitch us up with the umpiring last night, they are not going to let this one go.

npalm · Joined: 01 May 2005

This was an accident and there should be no case to answer but the AFL will play it safe and call it 'careless and high impact' and give him weeks. Then an overpaid lawyer will get him off via the appeal process.