Live Best 22

[stui magpie]

WHE is 186cm, Fas is 181 (basically a collingwood 6 footer) and Billy 177cm.

All are quick and good overhead. Of course you could play them all in the same forward line let alone the same side, it's all about playing time together and having a good system and understanding between each other so they can work together and not get in each others road.

Fas averaged 2 goals a game last year, Billy just under 2 in 2014/15. Both also average over 3 tackles per game. Hopefully that can lift as Blair and Cyril both average 4.7

[Raw Hammer]

That's the problem with our ever changing list. No continuity playing with each other. Each year we bring in 5 more recruits and the system takes half a year to click.

[didick]

[stui magpie]

[E]

This still looks like our best 22. the status of Brown and Hoskin-Elliot still unclear.

By the way, if we can get this team on the paddock and in top nick, this team beats most teams in the comp IMHO. No weak link at all.

Howe [Brown] Ramsey
Langdon Reid Scharenberg
Sidebottom Adams Varcoe
Mayne White Aish
Faz Moore [Hoskin-elliot]

Grundy, Pendles, Treloar

De Goey, Wells, Broomhead, Elliot?

[MightyMagpie]

My version post-Nathan Brown FA departure:

FF Elliott White Fasolo
HF Mayne Moore Pendlebury
C Wells Greenwood Aish
HB Howe Reid Sidebottom
B Varcoe Goldsack Ramsay
R Grundy Treloar Adams
Int Crisp Langdon Maynard DeGoey
Emg Wills Oxley Blair

Depth in VFL (some may overtake Rd1 best 22): Smith, Keeffe, Sinclair, Cox, Scharenberg, Broomhead, Phillips, Crocker, Sier, Thomas


(Assuming Cloke, Frost, Witts and Marsh depart - yet to be confirmed).

[Rush Stand Wing]

B Goldsack Keefe Howe
HB Adams Reid Maynard
C Varcoe Treloar Wells
HF Mayne White Sidebottom
F Blair Moore Fasolo
Foll Grundy Pendlebury Wills
Int Aish Greenwood Crisp De Goey
Em Hoskin-Elliot, Crocker, Smith, Oxley, Cox, Phillips
Other Elliot, Ramsay, Scharenberg, Sinclair, Langdon, Keefe, Thomas, Sier

[Rush Stand Wing]

B Goldsack Keefe Howe
HB Adams Reid Maynard
C Varcoe Treloar Wells
HF Mayne White Sidebottom
F Blair Moore Fasolo
Foll Grundy Pendlebury Wills
Int Aish Greenwood Crisp De Goey
Em Hoskin-Elliot, Crocker, Smith, Oxley, Cox, Phillips
Other Elliot, Ramsay, Scharenberg, Sinclair, Langdon, Keefe, Thomas, Sier

[roar]

^^No offence but that is a terrible 22.

[HAL]

I think ^^No offence but that is more than that.

[Rush Stand Wing]

[E]

4 new members of our best 22 from the outside (HE, Wells, Dunn and Mayne) and 3 new members of our best 22 from injury (Scharenberg, Ramsey and Broomhead). That's a third of the team.

Pretty sure Elliot would be in the best 22 but have grave doubts he will play at his best again.

Do people generally agree that these 7 inclusions are an upgrade on the 7 players that this team might keep out:

Brown, Crisp, Blair, Williams, Cloke, Smith and Maynard.

[Number 35]

---------- 2017 Premiers -------------

B/ HowThe? Mr.White MaynHard
HB/ PendleBURY Mr.Reid ScharenBERG
C/ JEThomas Mr.Adams LikeWaterWells
HF/ The Faz Mr.Moore Steel
F/ Billy the Kid The Cowboy ManicMayne
Foll: GRUNDY TheRoar4Treloar Crispy

Ace WHE Mr.Green DEGOEEEEY

[Raw Hammer]

FB | Smith Dunn Varcoe
HB | Howe Reid Scharenberg
C | Sidebottom Adams Wells
HF | Mayne White Hoskin-Elliott
FF | Fasolo Moore Elliott
R | Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
IC | Greenwood DeGoey Aish Crisp Ramsay Broomhead Langdon Maynard Keeffe Thomas Blair Oxley Wills Crocker Goldsack Marsh Cox Philips Sinclair

Positions for debate: Full Back line, Scharenberg (injury), Wells to half back, Aish to a wing, CHF...there's a lot of flexibility, and not too many weak links skill-wise and smarts-wise. But it will take time to gel...

[MatthewBoydFanClub]

My Rd 1 side (very early days with a lot to play out):

Ramsay Dunn Howe
Maynard Reid Varcoe
Sidebottom Wells Aish
De Goey White WHE
Fasolo Moore Mayne
Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
Int. Adams Crisp Wills Sinclair

Out (from rd22): Cloke Williams Brown Blair Smith Crocker Phillips Greenwood Oxley Goldsack Marsh
In: Moore Reid Ramsay Sinclair Dunn WHE Mayne Wells Fasolo Adams