Is Josh Fraser 1 year away from...

Rohan · Posted: Sun Mar 16, 2003 9:01 pm

But Greggy, Chris Scott is in the top 5 players of possibly the best team of the last 20 years. Chris Judd is in the top 5 of a side that struggled to make the 8 last year.

Chris has won a Rising Star unlike Judd, made the AA side and going by Mikey's rating, is a far better player.

Keep on clutching cobber.

Rohan · Posted: Sun Mar 16, 2003 9:11 pm

I would swap Josh but I wouldn't include Neon in the trade.

Neon and Didak will be a great combination for Collingwood and we currently have a surplus of quality midfielders.

Your claim about Judd being the best ever APS footballer is a tad unrealistic. Chris Scott has already outperformed Judd in his first year by winning the rising star in a deeper (quality wise) field.

Rohan · Posted: Sun Mar 16, 2003 9:19 pm

STOKA35 · Joined: 06 Feb 2003 Location: Mount Barker. South Australia

I like josh he has the talent maybe a stint at willi might shake him up a bit as he has had a pretty easy ride playing senior football maybe mick could give him the challenge to dominate at willi for a month then bring him back josh has played 69 senior games now.

Rohan · Posted: Sun Mar 16, 2003 9:49 pm

So Greggy a player who:

wins two premierships
finishes top 5 in these premiership years
wins a best and fairest
makes the AA side
wins the Rising Star

is worse than a player who didn't win a Rising Star and finised top 5 in the best and fairest in the worst top 8 side in the last 4 years?

Is that the same logic that thinks Richardson had 5 good years?

Laughing

Nicholas · Joined: 06 Mar 2003 Location: Melbourne

Josh is the most disappointing high hyped player we have recruited in some time. He should pull his finger out otherwise he won't be this onece in a generation player everyone was saying he would be.

Brown26 · Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2003 10:40 am

lay off josh will ya.

don't oyu have anyone else to pick on? Cause you sure seem to need someone to bag. I think his last full game was great, and the only bit he played in the preseason GF was great also, so maybe, here's an idea, wait and see how he plays this year before we drop him to the reserves!

no - what a stupid idea. let's just trade him now. I'm sure brissy will take him for chris scott - a player who is nothing special but rides on the sucess of everone else in the team doing the hard work. don't get me wrong he's ok, but not in the top five at brissy for tallent, which is not necessarily what the best a fairest goes on.

so let's just trade josh - give him to adelaide, port or brissy and you give them the gf.

- Ben

MissMagpie_20 · Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2003 12:01 pm

WELL SAID BEN!