Who would you select for Collingwood?

[BUCKS]

If you could select only one of these delisted players, who would you pick for Collingwood and why?

1. Adam Houlihan (GEEL)
2. Brett O'Farrell (HAW)
3. Brett Backwell (CARL)
4. Ben Brobbins (BRIS)
5. Gary Moorcroft (ESS)
6. Paddy Steinfort (RICH)
7. Aaron James (RICH)
8. Adrian Fletcher (FREM)
9. Murray Vance (CARL)
10. Adam White (CARL)
11. Scott Cummings (WCT)
12. Adam Chatfield (CARL)
13. Jordan Doering (CARL)
14. Heath Culpitt (CARL)
15. Jason Mooney (GEEL)
16. John Spaull (NTH)
17. Clayton Lasscock (NTH)
18. Matthew Collins (MELB)
19. Ben Beams (MELB)
20. Fabian Francis (PORT)
21. Tony Delaney (STKL)
22. Brett Knowles (STKL)
23. Matthew Young (STKL)
24. Tim Elliott (STKL)
25. Ben Walton (STKL)
26. Andrew Donnelly (WCT)
27. David Antonowicz (WCT)
28. Paul Dooley (FOOTS)




[This message has been edited by BUCKS (edited 29 October 2001).]

[This message has been edited by BUCKS (edited 29 October 2001).]

[Legga]

I think you would have to look at
Houlihan, O'Farrell, Moorcroft, Steinfort, Fletcher, vance, White, Doering, Mooney, Collins, and Dooley.
This may be a long list to consider, but I think all of these players have something that may aid us in the long run.

[MarkT]

I am not sure that I would drop anyone off our list for that lot. Basically they are players rejected by other clubs and some not for the first time. Moorcroft could be a handy free pickup and O'Farrell could be handy if the medico's cleared him because we need a ruckman.

[ed healey]

The one i would pick is not on the list
1.Paul Lindsay ruckman SANFL
2.Brayden Lyle Port have delisted him.
3.Ryan Turnbull WAFL ruckman.

[buckers5]

houlihan
moorcroft
o'farrel
flecther
vance
francis

these r the players i would consider but i think for our needs o'farrel might be the player we might go for moorcroft fletcher and francis would add much needed strength to our midfield and vance would stiffen our defence i think we will go for 1 recycled player and houlihan would be the priority as a midfielder not a small forward

[Brown26]

Houlinhan is useless to us - we have better younger players tahn him.

O'Farell and Fransis are the ones I would consider, though probably not Fransis cause he's too old.

Turnball isn't much use to us I don't think - he was underated at WCE by some, but his work ethic may not be good enough for MM I would imagine. And he's older...

Lade would be interesting - a gamble with injury but could be a possibility - and
Ben Beams maybe if you're looking for a back - but only at a deep deep pick. He'll only be useful for one or two years, then bye bye.

We don't need much vcause we've got good young guys coming thorugh - take more from the young guys draft - they're the future.


Pies for Premiers 2002, 3, 4, 5, 6....

[Lockyer24]

1. FLETCHER

2. O'FARRELL

3. DOERING

We'd only take 2 players max though I reckon

[deanricho]

you dont have him their but I would take the now de-listed aaron lord

[Millane42]

Fletcher or Francis

[CQ]

ay theres more now.

ahmat and robran (ess).

maybe we can get ahmat back! joking.

249

[WhyPhilWhy?]

Could we pick Aaron James, just so we could have the pleasure of delisting him again?

Any year we beat Carlton is a good year

[Brown26]

Our main problems were our ruck and our backline - now we have O'Farell and Robran available. I wouldn't think they'd both be around for our picks though. (when's our second pick?)

Pies for Premiers 2002, 3, 4, 5, 6....

[dallas]

fabian francis for sure this guy is a star and will take pressure of obree and buckley. If he's taken then robran.