carlscum next!!!and best 5 pies of all time?

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

From my lifetime...
1) Peter Daicos
2) Nathan Buckley
3) Darren Millane
4) Graham Wright (Can't believe no one has put him in!)
5) Tony Francis

"Good 'Ol Collingwood Forever"

[Fletch]

1. Nathan Buckley
2. Darren Millane
3. Peter Daicos
4. Gavin Brown
5. Mick Mcguane

Special mention to Len Thompson and Peter Mckenna, also to the tough guys like Magro(that hit on Jezza was legendary), Weiderman(My Dads favourite) and Des Tudedenham who is simply awesome in the highlights I've seen of him, a real toughnut who could play.

The next generation of superstars look promising as well i.e. Tarrant, Fraser, Tarks, Didak and Nick Davis are the stand outs.

__________________
'Some people believe football is a matter of life and death. I'm very disappointed with that attitude. I can assure you it is much, much more important than that.' Legendary Liverpool Manager, the great Bill Shankly.

[Mr Pieman]

In no particular order:

Peter Daicos
Len Thompson
Peter Moore
Des Tuddenham
Peter McKenna

CARN THE PIES

[Spongo]

Best Six of All time (Some are based purely on legend so I am willing to stand corrected by people who actually saw them)

1. Brown - the man's courage alone for our wonderful club. His omission from the team of the century is an absolute insult to everything them man has done and a footballing tragedy.

2. Millane - Buckley with more grunt and maybe a bit better flair in front of goal

3. Coventry - either one but especially Gordon

4. Peter Moore - last brownlow medalists

5. Lou Richards - brave and skillful

6. Jack Regan - Prince of Fullbacks

Honourable mentions

Buckley, Mcguane, Rose brothers, Kyne, Picken

Crystal ball

Fraser - oooohh, boy. We got a good one here. Will make Carey look amatuerish

[Joel]

Hasn't this been done before?

JDF

[London Dave]

Of course its been done before, buts its fun Joel.........

In no particular order, I liked as a top 5

Tuddy
Fabulous Phil
Daics
Millane
Bucks

+ Thommo, Wayne Richardson, Billy Picken, Tony Shaw and Hot Lips McKenna.

The greatest, who no one has mentioned yet is of course Rene Kink!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anyone know how much he weighs nowadays???

[Lockyer24]

1. Nathan Buckley
2. Gavin Brown
3. Peter Daicos
4. Darren Millane
5. Graham Wright/Sav Rocca

[B&W Phantom]

Here are my top 5.
1. Daics
2. Nathan Buckley
3. Lou Richards
4. Peter Mckenna
5. Peter Moore

[Greg J]

Joel, do some digging and see if people have changed their choices since last time. I think I am about to.

1. Peter Daico, a demi god.
2. Gavin Brown, I used to put him on my State electoral ballot and vote for him.
3. Peter Moore, until he went to Melbourne.
4. Peter McKenna, even went to see him play for Preston in the VFA.
5. Nathan Buckley, star is continuing to rise. I vote for Nathan in state elections now.

Greg J