Geelong offers Gardiner and 2nd round pick

[CQ]

josh hunt is a player i would be interested in if geelong wanna do any deals, had a few injuries but has recovered a fair bit this year. would be better than gardiner! id want more than just him if it was for pick 7 tho.

then again we could just keep pick 7 and get ourselves another danny roach!

[labrooy]

[CQ]

yes chapman is a good player, havent really payed that much attention 2 wojinski tho so dont know.

[vinnie_vegas69]

I'd probably take Moloney, Gardiner and pick #32 for Pick #7, Moloney is gonna be a very good player, Gardiner's better than people are giving him credit for, and we do get a pick as well.

I think I'd prefer that deal to the Chapman/Wojcinski deal, as Moloney's a better player than either of those guys.

[3rd degree]

Gardiner lacks confidence. Chapman is good at been angry and is a decent goal sneak and his grunt could be handy round the middle - well take him and the other bloke!

[BBHS]

the name charlie gardner is enough reason not to get him. Maybe we can get Henry Playfair in a stupid name package deal.

[Rob8]

Charlie Gardiner, Brent Moloney & pick 32

for

Pick 7

I say do it!!!! - Gardner will be that 3rd or 4th tall forward that Williams will never be and Moloney will provide us with some grunt, long kicking and extra promising youth. Pick 7 is a gamble anyway (Re: Danny Roach) and we also receive a pick in this deal which can be either retained or on traded to say West Coast for Chad Morrison.

[BBHS]

I prefer the gold 104 deal myself

[Johnson#26]

No way! Gardiner is honest at best and will never be good while Moloney is good but together they and a 2nd rounder aren't pick 7 matrerial

[rand corp]

Oh dear!

[Brown26]

nup - not worth it. We don't need a forward (Tarrant, Rocca, Cam Cloke, Fraser, Davidson, we've got enough) and we don't need a HBF, we need a midfield, and we need Tenace, Kelly, Bartell. Molony would be ok but not for pick seven. Make them squirm for another day and then see if they're still untouchable.

- Ben

[Joel]

There is no way you would trade pick 7 for Gardiner, you just wouldn't do it. I would prefer to take a risk with a young kid.

[Streak]

We may not get to deal with Geelong. I just heard a 3-way trade scenario was floated between Essendon, Port and Fremantle:

Fremantle gets Carr;
Port Adelaide gets Mark Johnson;
Essendon gets Ryley Dunn from Freo and their first pick (#11).

This was reported on afl.com.au. So, if Essendon are genuinely interested in Wojcinski they may offer Geelong pick #11 which, on Thursday or Friday afternoon, will be looking pretty good for Ottens.

So perhaps we keep #7. I know it's crazy but I have a strong feeling Richard Tambling is coming to Lexus.

[Johnson#26]

[3rd degree]

Where does Paul Chambers fit into all this don't Richmond want him for Ottens?