Top 5 disappointing Players

2cold · Joined: 14 Feb 2003

Ok Guys who is your "Top 5" for letting the team down and not performing because at the moment we are mediocre.

1- A. Rocca
2- A.Didak
3- S. Obree
4- S.Mcee
5- S.Prestigiacomo

go_pies_03 · Joined: 20 Apr 2003 Location: Australia

Presi has been great....how can you possible have him in your top 5 for letting the team down.

JLC · Posted: Mon Jun 16, 2003 4:43 pm

How many good games has Presti played this year. He missed a few games with injury and hasnt been that good imo.

Melbourne was one good game. What were the others ??

jlc

magpie24 · Joined: 01 Aug 2000 Location: Hurstbridge Melb Vic

Wheres Jonno,the turn over king?

JLC · Posted: Mon Jun 16, 2003 4:53 pm

Maybe this topic should be a top 10 ??

I dont think 5 is long enough....lol

jlc

Miss_Lisey_Molloy · Posted: Mon Jun 16, 2003 4:56 pm

aww..... u people are so cruel, lol! i could never ever single poor lil unfortunate players out like that!!

but umpires on the other hand........

Love always, Alyssa xoxo

magpie24 · Joined: 01 Aug 2000 Location: Hurstbridge Melb Vic

Thats gotta a laugh out of me John

M@®© · 1972 Joined: 13 Apr 2003 Location: Victoria - Rowville

Top 5 how about the whole team its a team sport there all to blame for the season

http://collingwood.rules.it/

magpie24 · Joined: 01 Aug 2000 Location: Hurstbridge Melb Vic

Agreed P4P,if your side dont want to run you lose.
Sad

There is no way Presti can stop his opponent if the midfield aint running!

Im starting to think we need a Bob Rose or Woey(Melbourne) game to fire us up(Jezz we were very flat)

Cam · Posted: Mon Jun 16, 2003 5:21 pm

to put a positive slant on things the only blokes that can hold their heads up and be relatively guilt free are (in no real order)

Josh Fraser
Chris Tarrant
Scott Burns
Nathan Buckley
Brodie Holland
Rhyce Shaw
Paul Licuria
maybe Lokan (he's a first year player after all)

We are simply not the hard at the nut team we were last year. In 2002 we belted teams up and that made up for our skill shortcomings. This year we have definitely improved skill wise (look at our stoppage stats, marks etc) but have fallen away badly in the body-beatings we delivered last year. The Kangaroos or maybe West Coast of 2003 are the Collingwood of 2002. Hate to admit that, but its true. Or is true thus far.

WAKE UP AND SMELL THE ROSES BOYS BEFORE DOROTHY THE DINOSAUR EATS THEM!!!

sorry, dunno where that came from

JLC · Posted: Mon Jun 16, 2003 5:38 pm

Kinnear hasnt been a disappointment this year as i didnt expect much anyway....lol Molloy doesnt make my list as i dont rate him that highly in the first place so he hasnt disappointed me much.

1. Rocca (From Grand Final Heroics to wearing a glove by Round 12)

2. Prestigiacomo (From Unobtrusive to unimpressive)

3. Didak (Still young so has time on his side)

4. Woewodin (Expected more to be honest but maybe i over rated him to begin with)

5. Leon Davis (Personal problems aside hasnt played well when we have needed him in the big games this year)

jlc

mandy · Joined: 03 Jun 2001 Location: Glen Iris

Budgie · Joined: 02 May 2002 Location: Vic

1. Rocca: easily has been the most disappointing player at the club this year. At the moment his forms warrants him been dropped which is terrible for someone of his ability

2. Molloy: Should have been dropped about 2 or 3 weeks ago. His season has been terrible. I know he breaks packs open but it would be nice if he touched the ball more than 6 or 7 times a game. And some goals from him wouldn't go astray.

3. Didak: Remeber this bloke is a number 3 pick in the draft and has done nothing in 2 and a years except have a good wizard cup. Can't handle the physical and mental pressures of AFL.

4. Mckee: Gone from number one ruckman at start of year to now being the number 4 ruckman at the club (cloke and richards both ruck ahead of him at willi)

5. Freeborn and Rup: Gone from regulars to reserve players.

Joe · Joined: 01 Jun 2003

Agree with u Cam that the hardness is missing.
How is Dorothy the dinosaur anyways.lol

AGE · Joined: 06 Sep 2002 Location: Docking Bay 94

It's hard to say who's been bad who's been good because some players have ben up and down.
Rocca was good when we were winning, and Davis was out of touch when we were winning too. But then regained form after the birth of his child.
So overall for the whole season would be (in no order)

5. Rocca (having a shocker year)
4. Didak (up and down form, has been ok the last 2-3 weeks)
3. Davis (see Didak)
2. Woewodin (expected more from him with being a BL winner)
1. Williams (great in the Wizzy Cup, couldn't follow through to the H&A)

5 Best (in no particular order)
1. Tarrant
2. Buckley
3. Licuria
4. Lonie
5. Burns