Changes

[peter_pies4ever]

This week's changes should be as follows.
In: J.Cloke, M.McGough, D.Swan
Out: S.Prestigiacomo(injured), L.Davis, A.Williams

A.Williams is out of form at the moment and a week in the two's might be good for him. L.Davis should be back with Williamstown as well as he made no contribution last week.

[CAAS]

[Brown26]

I wouldn't drop Davis either - he wasn't THAT good last week, but he's definitly improving and I reckon to drop him might ruin his confidence. but the other two yes. Or walker if he's showing anything.

- Ben

[i_coulda_been_a_champ]

i dont care anymore whether davis kicks goals or not as i think this is a little limiting on him . would like to see him get a bit(lot ) of the ball upfield where he can use his pace in a straight line to forward line and his beautiful passing skills to forwards on lead . how much would they luv that

[Willie]

I wouldn't say Leon made no contribution last week, but the amount of times he took a blind snap at the goals, even when he had a bit of time to line up I think cost us at least a couple of goals.

[lsdswooper]

It might be worthwhile giving leon a role of swapping between wing and forward pocket.

I reckon our rocca and tarrant would do well one-on-one with neons speed in delivering the ball into the forward line. Neon and Lonie could work well on the wing?
if neon goes foward as a defensive foward, he has to drag his player with him.

Maybe this releases brodie for a forward pocket goal sneak role? although holland's best game thsi year was his blinder against the crows in the BP!

Shaw seems to have fitted in well across half back. His pace is a real bonus.

We've gotta get some slick pace into the side. The doggies almost knocked off carlton with their forward push of the ball at all costs. Static footy is bad footy!

[zoia]

do people have shit for brains or somthing the love child is a great player his playing ok down the wing not as good as the wizz fizz cup but hey his still gettin the ball down to the fowards

[Daniel]

magpies_1983.... didn't u say didak was from Perth?

[Daniel]

OUT: Presti, Williams

IN: J Cloke, McGough

peterpies.... L Davis did OK last week.

[zoia]

arghhh typo his from adlaide and leave williams alone plz stop picking on him

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

I would have...

IN: J.Cloke, M.McGough
OUT: A.Williams, S.Prestigiacoma

Although, I want to see Cameron Cloke get a game very soon. Has been rucking very well with Willy from all reports and been good around the ground. I think he deserves at least one shot, to see whether or not he is up to it at this level yet.

[Molly]

yeah i agree that williams cld do with a week in the reserves - he hasn't been playing well for the past few weeks, including before he got knocked out. The day that happened i thought we actually played better after he was taken off.

Mc Gough is the obvious choice to bring in, along with Cloke for presti.

[chalky]

Tough to drop anyone really. Looking back (always easy) we didn't play that badly for the majority of the game - always playing catch up though.

I cannot see MM calling up C Cloke, J Cloke perhaps. MM has always rated our rucks. A combination of McKee, Fraser ( back to form)and Rocca plus any number of third men up has been moderately successful.
Individual ruck opposition may be statistically superior in taps, but as a group I feel we fare better than most expect.

1 change - OUT: Presti IN: J.Cloke
MCG will just have to wait a little longer I'm afraid

[Devils Advocate]

Magpie_1983...you really need to do a spell check before you send mail, if you want people to take you seriously 'adlaide'

[scoobydoo]

out: presti,scotland
in: J.cloke,Goughy

I know a few of you guys love Scotland but he doesnt seem to EVER get much time on the ground when playing in the senior's.Maybe M.M finds it hard to match him up with someone but either way i would like to see McGough come in