In's and Out's

[I@n S]

What on earth.. Is it just me or are these dumb?

In: Wakes, Shaw, Scotland (yay about time) and cole

Out: Kinnear, Rup, McGough and Cloke.. WTF!!!

The good, the bad and the ugly:
Good: Wakes is back after touching the poor soft umpires who are treated like gods..
Scotland: Remember the finals game agaist Adelaide

Bad: McGough out? And I hate this talk that hes just a Wet Weather player just because he won the anzac day medal last season.

Ugly: Cloke out? Again WTF. Our best defender or close to it?
What's he done wrong?

[I@n S]

oh and then theres the Molloy blow, Rocca no-show. I think they'll play. Can we win without Rocca?

[Banksy]

You obviously haven't seen the pies play lately mate.
Mcgough getting dropped is justified.He can't hit targets is too slow and isn't manning up when the opposition rebounds.
Cloke is also justified.Getting led to the footy,also too slow and in the last few weeks he's been getting a thrashing from the oppostion forwards..(Jonothan Brown,Adam Goodes).
I hope both find form and can come back into the side..especially Cloke.

[I@n S]

I have seen them play laterly. Yes you're right about Mcgough & Cloke but I'm one for giving them another chance. I blame MM for Cloke being down because why would you play Cloke in the farward line?
As for Mcgough I think he's down on confidence just like the rest of the team are at the moment. If we had better backups than Shaw and Cole i'd be up for dropping him but I don't think Shaw can do the job. Wile with Cole he's still learning.