Collingwood are gone for 2003. Bring on 2004!

[AnthonyC]

This topic is going to the shizenhousen.

Quite Simply, it is Round 6. The original post is crap, end of story.
Mount a counter argument, if you can.

Disclaimer: Probably originally posted when desperately upset

[Lone Ranger]

Culprit, Millane42 is not being attacked for "going against popular opinion". He is being attacked for calling the players "over-rated hacks" and saying Malthouse cant coach. That is personal abuse and should not be tolerated.
We have some players who need to improve their skills but we DO NOT have hacks. Only the other 15 clubs have hacks.

[Millane42]

hey Lone Ranger

With those 2 points i was being ironic - we all know MM is a super coach but he isn't coaching well at present, and the team is a champion team which made the GF last year, but are not performing. - there is a difference, i guess it isn't easy writing in an ironic tone.

[stik35]

Thank you for clarifying those 2 points Millane 42.

Now, will you watch the game on Saturday night?

I'll bet if we win you'll change your tune.

[Lone Ranger]

Good to hear Millane42. I would agree that Malthouse hasnt been at his best for the last 2 weeks. I know sometimes it can be frustrating but I just hate it when the abuse gets personal.
If someones yells "that was a shocking kick McGough" for example, I can live with it. But is someone yells "you are a dud McGough" I will have a go at them.
I once sat behind a few of the players back in the Christian, Manson days. When frustrated supporters yelled "that is a shocking kick" or "terrible decision" the players just sat there. When someone got personal and yelled "You are a hack Manson" all the players heads spun around. I thought Christian was going to deck the guy!

[Millane42]

I definitely agree with that Lone Ranger - i was sitting in the ponsford stand on GF day and this idiot in front of me was yelling at Buckley "you're useless buckley, you're hopeless" while his 6 year kid was sitting next to him. Then about 2 minutes later buckley sets up a goal, then kicks one himself and all of us around him gives him a stare and a jibe and he says "oh yeah that was good, but he should be doing that all the time".

Apart from Millane and Daicos, Buckley is the best player i have seen. A champ like that shouldn't be abused for a few errant kicks now and then when he gets so much of the ball.

And stk 35 i've course i'll be watching this week...nervously......

[swooper]

i wonder if millane42 will still think we're gone if we beat Adelaide on Sat night??!

[Lorelei]

[GO RUPERT 10]

For gods sakes its only round 7 i mean ill admit i was pretty pissed off at our performance against the swans ,but look at last year when we went into the finals with ordinary form.i bet you were on the bandwagon during the finals last year.Supporters like you and chris robbo who threw his collingwood jumper on the field during the game really should give it up and barrack for richmond cause theyre used to having feral supporters

[Sammy Gee]

milane..u r spot on...this year collingwood doesnt look like improving at all.... replace the skipper, but keep bux in the team, best player, not so good skipper, and c'wood might make 7th or 8th, but if they persist with bux as skipper, no finals campaign this year... sorry... but the truth must be said..

[GO RUPERT 10]

replace buckley as captain?are you out of your mind hes one of the best leaders this club has ever had,i mean did you see the 2002 gf when he led from the front and busted his ass for the team. i really dont belive some supporters .there is no player in the team who can replace bucks as skipper. i think im gonna ly down for a while.its been a long week
first a supporter throws his jumper on the field,then someone says we are gone after round 6 AND now some clown wants bucks replaced as skipper.Lord have mercy!

[gopies 2003]

Rupe, I think you will Sammy is a troll (otherwise known as a Collingwood wanna be).

[Blanch]

Sammy Gee, you are on here to stir up peoples emotions. I'm asking you nicely in front of everyone here to stop with the games. Humour is one thing but to deliberately agitate and annoy people is getting beyond a joke. You are entitled to your opinion but I'm accusing you of sh*tstirring, not putting forward an opinion that is open to discuss.

Stop with the rubbish please.

[McGuane's 77 Bounces]

You call yourself a big supporter of the Pies Millane 42, but after 2 years you still haven't attended a Sydney Collingwood Supporters Function.....We watch the team win loose or draw every week and beg, steal and borrow off the T.V stations here in Sydney to show something on the Pies...I guess we will not be seeing you anytime soon.
We are 60 members strong and growing every day, I just hope you don't jump on that bandwagon when Eddie and the team host the planned functions at the end of the year in Sydney.
Real supporters pitch in and support the club from the ground up...Take a look at yourself and you are not alone (where has GI Jane gone)..

Craig

[Go_The_Mighty_Magpies]

Millane42, We are not gone for the year 3-3 after round 6? come on! I refuse to give up on them because if they win the premiership this year, your going to be damn sorry you said all that.
I hope you stick to your word and don't watch them tonight.
If this is your attitude after 3-3 i dont even want to think about your attitude when we were doing really bad, and also you don't deserve to use Millanes name. You probably hav had enuf critism from this by now but your unbelevable...

Still miss you PANTS